How to choose a Shopify theme

A theme is not a design. It is the frame the store has to live in. Here is what decides whether you buy the right one.

Author: Henry Navntoft, Shopify developer

Most people pick a theme from the homepage. That is the page the theme is best at selling. The problem shows up on the product page, in the cart, and the day you need one more field the theme never planned for. A theme is the frame you will edit for the next few years. Choose for that, not for a demo with twelve products.

What the demo hides

  • The product page with variants, accessories, and a long description. Not a hero image and a buy button.
  • Filters on a collection of several hundred products. The demo has twenty.
  • Mobile. Most purchases happen there. The desktop demo says nothing about it.
  • How much is locked into sections, and how much needs a developer the moment you want to deviate.

Free, paid, or your own

Dawn and the other free themes from Shopify are an honest start if the catalog is simple and you can live with the look. A paid theme buys sections you would otherwise build: a lookbook, bundles, heavier filters. A custom theme, or a paid one rebuilt properly, makes sense when the brand must not look like the other stores on the same theme. It costs more to start, and less on the day an update would have overwritten your edits.

Do not buy the theme for its app promises

Themes advertise that they “work with” a long list of apps. That means the app can be installed. It does not mean upsells, reviews, and a size guide can sit on the same product page without fighting for space. Choose the theme for its structure. Choose apps after, and only the ones the theme does not already solve. If the choice is a theme edit or an app, read app or theme.

Once the theme is chosen, the work is making it your store: type, the product template, collections, and whatever has to be fast. That is store work. A theme you already have and have outgrown is often a move inside Shopify, not a new project from scratch.

About the author

Henry Navntoft. Shopify developer at Globus in Copenhagen. Builds stores, apps, and migrations for Danish and international brands.

Q&A

Can we switch themes later without losing content?

Products, orders, and pages stay. Sections, menus, and anything that only lives in the theme settings do not. The more you have built into the theme files, the more expensive the switch is.

Should we start on a free theme?

Yes, if you can sell with it. No, if the first thing you do is ask a developer to turn it into something else. Then you pay twice.

What should we test before we buy a paid theme?

The product page with your variants, a collection with filters, and mobile. A demo with twelve products does not show how the store feels with your catalog.

Can apps fix a weak theme?

No. Apps add features on top. They do not fix a heavy product page or a structure the theme never had. Choose the theme first. Apps after.

More guides

Want us to look at your store?

Tell us what you sell and where it stalls. We’ll say whether it is a theme, an app, or a move.

Get in touch

How to use the theme guide

A theme is the frame the store has to live in, not a picture of the homepage. The guide is written so you do not buy a theme and then pay to turn it into something else. If you can sell with a free or a paid theme, start there. If the first thing you do is ask a developer to remake it, you pay twice. Your own theme is for when the look and the code have to stay updatable when Shopify moves Online Store 2.0.

The Shopify store service is where we build or repair the frame. The guide is the argument. Write which theme you are looking at and what it cannot do. We will say whether you should buy it, leave it, or have something built that you can own.

Images, collections, and copy are not the theme’s fault, but they decide whether the theme can carry the store. Include them in the note. An empty product page cannot be saved by a more expensive theme.

Link the theme you are looking at if you have one. Write what you want to change first. If the first change is to rebuild the theme, the answer is often not to buy it. The guide is there to save that detour.

A theme is the right purchase when you want to change content, order, and a few sections, and leave the rest alone. It is the wrong purchase when the first change is to rebuild the product page, the cart, or a language. Then you pay for a starting point you will not use, and you are left with a copy that cannot be updated the day Shopify moves the theme. The guide is there to stop that purchase before it happens.

Link the theme you are looking at and write the first change in one sentence. If the change is a metafield, a different image layout, or a section a merchant should be able to move, the theme may be right. If the change is a rule that must talk to a warehouse or survive a later theme change, it is an app or a theme app extension, and the theme should be chosen because it is stable, not because it looks like a mockup. Write to hello@globus-dev.com with the link. We will say whether you should buy it, before you pay for a starting point you will not use.